Blogging Rule #816: Comment Notification

Let’s get real for just a minute.  I know people don’t wake up, turn on their computer, and type in the browser window

 h t t p : / / A r e W e C o n n e c t e d .  c o m

to see the latest happenings on the site.

People arrive here from various referral sources.  That could be a Google Search, a link from a social network like Twitter or Facebook.  They might even be reading the newest posts in a feed reader (my preferred method).  How they arrive at the blog is not what I’m concerned with here.  It’s what happens later.

referral sources

We Want Comments

Comments are social proof.  Somebody arrived at my post, read it and did something.  They might not have agreed with me but they responded. If and when people do leave a comment a good blogger will respond to those comments.  That encourages discussion, and that’s always a great thing for a writer.

So as a blogger, when we actually succeed at getting someone to comment, here’s how we can screw it all up.

Lack of Comment Notification

If I left a comment on your blog and you replied did I hear it?  You asked me for my name and email address, did your blog send me a “Mike replied to your comment on…” email?  If it didn’t, did you actually expect me to check back periodically to see if anyone responded?  Really? That isn’t going to happen.

Blogging Rule #816:  Every blog MUST have a form of subscribe to comments

That could be a simple plugin like “Subscribe to Comments”.  It could also be any form of comment management system you like.

New to Comment Management?  Here’s a quick rundown of what they do.

  • Most all will allow you to sign in using the method of your choice (facebook, twitter, openid etc.).
  • Most will allow you to share your comment on various social networks.
  • Most will provide a pretty avatar of you next to your comment (have Gravitar?)
  • All will provide an extra layer of spam protection.
  • All will provide the comment writer with notification (with a link back to the post) so they know someone replied and the discussion can continue!

Disqus – This blog uses Disqus.  It has for along time.

Intensedebate – This is from the makers of wordpress (Automattic) so you know it’s going to work beautifully with most themes.

LiveFyre – Is new to me but it looks and operates much the same as the others.

Facebook Comments – I’ve debated putting this on but I can see the real value behind it. Most often (unless you deem otherwise) your comment on the blog is also published on your Facebook Wall for all your friends to see.  It’s also a link back to the post, thereby driving traffic back here.

Moral of the Story

So unless your blog is just for broadcasting and you are not interested in any form of dialogue…  Before you write that 1st post, you MUST have some sort of comment notification.  YOU MUST

If not – just create your posts and turn off all comments like Seth* does.

I read around 200 blog posts a day, I comment on those that are interesting to me.  If I see an article that doesn’t have comment notification I’ll skip it.  Why do you want to make me work harder?  Sorry, I’m moving on.

Do you do this too?

*  I’m kidding, you and I are not Seth, don’t even think you can go there!

Mike Mueller

Mike builds the custom Apps that create the Tabs that make Custom Facebook Pages special. He builds Discount WordPress Blogs and shoots commercial high def video. He's an avid hockey fan, rides a motorcycle (a really fast one), loves strong beer and good red wine.
Twitter   Facebook   LinkedIn   Blog      Flickr   Trulia   YouTube   Foursquare   Email

Website - Twitter - Facebook - More Posts

  • http://210consulting.com/ Jeremy Blanton

    I agree completely with what you said.  Add the plugin, it takes seconds to do so.

    • http://AreWeConnected.com mikemueller

      Wooo freakin Hooo!  I got’s a comment!  ;)

      Seriously – how could it be? Unless it’s Seth.

      • http://210consulting.com/ Jeremy Blanton

        and you know what was great? I got an email that you replied too :) Imagine
        that!

  • http://twitter.com/WaterwayRealty Mott Marvin Kornicki

    I must agree completely with Jeremy B, but I disagree with you, Mueller. I wanna know about the plugs that you talk about and Jeremy neglected to mention. #WTWY “btw” ? AreWeConnected? ?

    • http://AreWeConnected.com mikemueller

      Mott – For each system in the post I LINKED the title to their website.  Even the simplest “subscribe to comments” plugin. :)

  • http://www.biggerpockets.com Joshua Dorkin

    Is this thing on . . . testing? ;)

    • http://AreWeConnected.com mikemueller

      Joshua – nope it’s not.  LOL!